CLE Shedeur Sanders
NFL player. Position: QB. Team: CLE.
Quick Facts
- Position: QB
- Team: CLE (Cleveland Browns)
- Draft: 5th round, 144th overall, 2025 NFL Draft
- College: Colorado
2026 Outlook
Sanders is competing with Deshaun Watson for the Cleveland Browns' starting QB role heading into the 2026 season. His rookie year showed modest on-field production (1,400 yards, 7 TDs, 10 INTs in 7 starts, 3-4 record) after beginning the season as a backup. However, Sanders has distinguished himself off the field as a marketing phenomenon, earning a reported $17.7 million in NFLPA Group Licensing Income in 2025—breaking Tom Brady's previous record of $9.5 million—demonstrating elite brand-building ability for a fifth-round rookie. (per Shedeur Sanders earns reported $17.7 million in licensing income in 2025, breaking Tom Brady's record) As a dynasty sleeper, Sanders represents a non-zero chance at the Browns QB job in 2027 if he wins the 2026 competition and plays at a pedestrian level while the team exceeds expectations—making him a low-cost dynasty acquisition outside the top 25 of rookie drafts (per 12 Deep Dynasty League Sleepers for Fantasy Football: Undervalued Trade and Draft Targets (2026)).
In late March, Browns owner Jimmy Haslam praised Sanders' dedication to NFL preparation, noting Sanders spent most of the offseason in Cleveland working out early and was responsive to the demands of QB play. Haslam said Sanders "got an education in that" (referring to the difficulty of playing NFL QB) but showed signs of responsiveness: "His body looks better...my instincts are he'll come back ready to play" (per Jimmy Haslam says Shedeur Sanders 'got an education' on how to excel in the NFL, and...).
At late May OTAs, the competition with Watson remains deadlocked. OC Travis Switzer said neither QB has pulled ahead, with both splitting first-team reps and making equal progress on Todd Monken's system installation. (per Cleveland Browns News and Rumors May 29, 2026: Nobody Is Ahead, Which Is Somehow Progress)
To address historical WR struggles (0.9 yards per route in 2025—second-lowest in the league), the Browns added receiving targets including Ohio State WR Carnell Tate in the 2026 draft. Todd Monken's offense has historically emphasized vertical passing (8.7 air yards per attempt average with Ravens), positioning any successful Sanders tenure to feature more downfield throws. (per 2026 NFL Draft: 20 ideal team-prospect fits that could actually happen in Round 1)
By early June, Sanders had begun trending upward. NFL insider Cameron Wolfe reported Sanders has impressed the Browns coaching staff over recent weeks at OTAs, with particular praise for his processing and decision-making improvements as he progresses down the field. Wolfe noted sources used the word "aura" to describe Sanders' impact, and HC Todd Monken—who initially wanted a decision before training camp—has pushed back the timeline, possibly due to Sanders' strong work. (per Shedeur Sanders' 'aura' has Browns rethinking QB race as $230m competition heats up)
August 24 decision — Watson named starter: After an extended preseason evaluation (Watson won Game 1, Sanders won Game 2), HC Todd Monken announced on Sunday, August 24 that Deshaun Watson will be the Browns' starting QB for Week 1 against Jacksonville. Monken's reasoning: "We felt over the course of training camp and the offseason that (Watson) was ahead of Shedeur...Shedeur's closed that gap, for sure. And that's a credit to him. We look forward to Shedeur continuing to grow as a player, but ultimately, we're about Week 1. Putting our best foot forward over the next three weeks." Notably, Monken stated he is "not anticipating" the starting QB situation to change on a week-to-week basis, suggesting Watson has a stable path as the primary starter. Sanders will remain as the backup QB and #2 on the depth chart, with opportunities to play if Watson struggles early or faces injury (per Browns name Deshaun Watson starting QB for Week 1 of 2026 NFL season)
August 27 league perception reality check: After Watson's decision was announced, external skepticism about Sanders' NFL future emerged from around the league. NFL front office personnel told CBS Sports they don't view Sanders as an NFL starting-caliber quarterback, with one staffer citing that he couldn't even beat out Watson "who hasn't played in an NFL regular season game since his first Achilles injury in 2024." Multiple front offices have reportedly indicated they wouldn't even trade for Sanders if he became available, expressing concerns about the "celebrity and distraction components" that come with managing such a high-profile backup. While Sanders showed positives (9-for-11 against Buffalo with 1 TD), scouts continue to question his arm strength, processing speed, and ability to hold the ball appropriately. (per What's next for Shedeur Sanders? NFL sources question whether Browns QB has a starting future - CBS Sports).
Monken has publicly stated both Sanders and Watson are "starting-level quarterbacks" and that he "leans one way or the other" with the QBs daily at OTAs. At mandatory minicamp in early June, Monken confirmed the QB competition will "bleed into training camp" rather than being decided by the end of minicamp. Monken said both have "played well enough to earn the right to compete" and that he'll need to see full pads and preseason games before making a final decision. (per Browns HC Todd Monken Not Interested in QB Brendan Sorsby; Latest On Team's QB Competition, Deshaun Watson, Shedeur Sanders QB competition will likely bleed into training camp)
Minicamp reality check (June 10): At the final day of mandatory minicamp, Monken flatly stated: "I'm not going to name a No. 1." Sanders got first-team reps on June 9, while Watson took the second team on the same day, with reps continuing to rotate. Monken emphasized both quarterbacks "functioned at a high level" and that he hasn't seen enough separation to decide. Without pads or live scrimmages, the decision will stretch into and possibly through training camp. While ESPN's Jeremy Fowler views Watson as having the inside track, Sanders' "aura" and strong work continue to keep the job competitive (per Shedeur Sanders or Deshaun Watson? Browns' Todd Monken still undecided at QB).
At mandatory minicamp (June 9-11), the rotation continued through the final day with no breakthrough. Monken said both QBs "played well enough to earn the right to compete" and that he needs to see full pads and preseason games before deciding. Sanders and Watson split first-team reps on the last day, with both described as "starting-level quarterbacks" capable of functioning at a high level in Monken's system. (per NFL 2026 minicamp takeaways: Browns' Deshaun Watson-Shedeur Sanders competition heating up)
Training camp (July 24): The Cleveland Browns will closely evaluate Deshaun Watson against rookie Shedeur Sanders. Both quarterbacks are earning extended opportunities throughout training camp after impressive offseason progress and recovery efforts. Head coach Todd Monken has stated both Sanders and Watson had "really good springs" and called it a positive time to be the Browns' head coach. New OC Todd Monken mentioned Sanders and Watson both impressing during spring practices and may have hinted they have the inside track to being the starter. The competition will continue into pads and early preseason, with the team not yet committing to one starter (per Todd Monken Reveals Insights on Browns' QB Battle and NFL Training Camp 2026: Live Updates, Injuries and Position Battles).
July 20 Athletic comprehensive preview: The Athletic's detailed cover story on the Browns QB competition confirmed Sanders is genuinely competitive with Watson heading into training camp. While Watson showed an early edge in OTAs with superior explosive plays downfield, Sanders has closed that gap significantly through minicamp and spring work. Monken explicitly stated both QBs "have played well enough to earn the right to compete" and will extend the evaluation through pads and preseason games. The critical unknown for Watson: he hasn't taken a live hit in nearly two years due to Achilles surgeries, making his ability to perform under pass rush an untested factor. Sanders, by contrast, has already proven durability in 2025, starting 7 games as a rookie despite a patchwork offensive line. Monken indicated the decision will likely extend to late August after evaluating both QBs in full pads and preseason games. For fantasy purposes, Sanders' viability hinges on winning a competition that won't be decided until late preseason, making him a late-round speculative QB in redraft formats if he emerges as the starter. (per Sizing up the Browns' QB options: Deshaun Watson, Shedeur Sanders or yet another search - The Athletic)
Personal life simplification (late July 2026): Sanders told The Nadeska Show by Apple Music he has made a conscious shift heading into his second season, simplifying his life away from football to maintain consistency in personal life. "I can't be consistent on the field and not have consistency in my personal life," Sanders said. "Whatever you do in your personal life is going to bleed into how you feel, so, if you're disciplined you're gonna make the right reads." Sanders emphasized understanding "how real life translates to the game" and credits this renewed focus as key to displaying the upside coaches have observed and making up ground on Watson heading into training camp. (per Browns QB Shedeur Sanders Touts Bold Change Heading Into Year 2)
Training camp outlook (July 9): As training camp approaches in two weeks, Bleacher Report's James Palmer reports Sanders has "closed the gap" on Watson significantly. Sanders has shown notable improvement in pocket presence and progression reading through OTAs and minicamp. Palmer emphasized Sanders is "making up ground" and improving on fundamentals, while sources indicate the Browns have no intention of trading Sanders despite the quarterback logjam. (per Shedeur Sanders May Have Inside Track in Cleveland Browns' Starting QB Battle, Analyst gives insight into Browns QB battle with training camp next)
Aug 12 training camp discipline test: During training camp two-minute drills under head coach Todd Monken, Sanders' first-team offense was plagued by pre-snap penalties, leading Monken to kick the unit off the field. Both Sanders and Watson's second unit also struggled with penalties and a sack, frustrating Monken. The competition remains deadlocked; Monken emphasized that mental mistakes (fixable discipline issues) will directly factor into the starting decision. Sanders will need to demonstrate consistency and protection protocol execution to separate from Watson (per Browns' Monken apologizes for being 'emotionally hijacked' by offense's penalties).
Preseason Week 1 debut: Mixed bag with turnovers (Aug 16): In his second preseason outing against Chicago, Sanders took over in the second half and showed explosive plays but also critical turnovers. He completed a 24-yard strike immediately, then fumbled a snap and had a tipped pass. Later, he threw a 35-yard deep ball but had pre-snap miscommunication leading to a stuffed fourth-down at Chicago's 5-yard line. He capped his day with an interception to cornerback Beanie Bishop Jr. Final stat line: 6-for-11, 79 yards, 1 INT. While Sanders showed the "most explosive throws of the day," his turnovers—particularly the interception on a critical drive—prevented him from separating from Watson. Coach Todd Monken left the competition completely open after the game, with Sanders getting a chance to respond in joint practices before the next preseason game vs Buffalo (per Did Deshaun Watson Show Enough To Earn Starting Role in His First Preseason Start? and NFL news, live updates: Mixed bag for Browns QBs).
Preseason Week 2 breakout (Aug 23): Sanders delivered a much stronger performance than Deshaun Watson in the Browns' preseason game against Buffalo, finishing 9-for-11 with 74 yards, 1 TD, and 1 INT. He came out "firing" after a weather delay, connecting on all four opening-drive passes including a fourth-down conversion and an 8-yard TD to Luke Floriea. Coach Monken praised Sanders extensively: "There's a lot there to like. He plays with a certain amount of confidence. He has gotten a lot better at getting rid of the ball." Sanders hit his first eight passes in a row before an interception, showing marked improvement from his preseason week 1 performance. Beyond the field performance, Sanders demonstrated leadership by defending Watson against booing from the crowd during a sideline interview: "I don't really feel comfortable when the whole stadium is booing and stuff because he's going out there, he's trying to put in work too, just how we all are." Sanders reiterated in postgame press conference: "Regardless of competition, we're all human beings. I think we all need to understand that." The strong outing and leadership keep the QB competition completely open heading into the final preseason games (per NFL preseason Week 2 winners and losers: Bo Nix shines in return, Deshaun Watson takes shot at Browns fans, Shedeur Sanders mesmerizes during 8-minute sideline interview, Shedeur Sanders Strongly Defends Deshaun Watson After Browns Fans Boo Him)
Late July prediction (July 14): Yahoo Sports analyst predicts Sanders could win the starting QB job "just a couple of weeks into training camp," noting his strong performance in spring drills and coaching staff's recognition of his improved processing and consistency. The prediction suggests Sanders has genuine momentum heading into mandatory camp (July 28) despite Watson's veteran status and contract commitments. If the prediction materializes, Sanders would inherit a receiver room with KC Concepcion, Denzel Boston, and elite TE Harold Fannin Jr. to support his second-year campaign, positioning him as a potential season-long sleeper QB if he wins the job. (per Prediction on Cleveland Browns QB Shedeur Sanders could come true just a couple of weeks into training camp)
Training camp emphasis (Aug 12): Coach Todd Monken's first camp focus centers on mental execution and discipline. When Sanders' first-team unit struggled with pre-snap penalties during two-minute drills, Monken emphasized that "those are under every player's control" and are a reflection of coaching. This highlights Monken's expectations for QB-led discipline and mental sharpness—qualities Sanders must demonstrate to separate himself from Watson in the competitive battle. Monken subsequently apologized to the team for his emotional outburst, acknowledging he should have handled the situation differently but reiterating his commitment to fixing these fixable mental mistakes. Sanders and the second-team unit also struggled with penalties, sacks, and false starts, further underscoring the mental execution gap Monken wants to address (per Browns' Monken apologizes for being 'emotionally hijacked' by offense's penalties, Monken apologizes for outburst over mishaps on offense - NFL.com).
Training camp Day 1 mixed results (July 29): Sanders worked on the second-team field with rookies KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston as receivers. He showed bright moments: a nice deep sideline route to Boston and a deep completion to Concepcion in 7-on-7s. However, he also struggled early in 11-on-11s, overthrowing receivers a couple of times and failing to make any highlight-reel plays. Overall, it wasn't the best day for either QB in the competition. The rotation continues, with Sanders taking first-team reps on Day 2 as part of Monken's deliberate two-spot strategy. (per Did Deshaun Watson or Shedeur Sanders work with the starters on the 1st day of training camp?)
July 23 coaching praise (late phase): As training camp approaches with three days remaining, ESPN reporter Daniel Oyefusi revealed that Browns coach Todd Monken has been "impressed with both Deshaun Watson and Shedeur Sanders during the offseason workout program" but that Sanders specifically has "impressed coaches with his grasp of the offense in recent months." Oyefusi cited Sanders' demonstrated ability to "decipher through a pass rush and make smart decisions" as critical to seizing the QB competition. While Watson remains healthy after Achilles surgeries, Sanders appears to be "making up ground" with improved processing and decisiveness in the QB battle heading into training camp. (per Browns' Shedeur Sanders Receives High Praise From Coaches Ahead of Training Camp, Browns' Deshaun Watson, Shedeur Sanders fuel ongoing QB debate, Browns QB Competition Deeper Than Shedeur Sanders vs. Deshaun Watson)
On June 11, Sanders revealed his approach to the QB battle differs from the typical "competition narrative." When asked about the QB race, Sanders downplayed the "competition" framing, saying: "I think the way how y'all look at things is different than how we look at things. We look at coming to practice every day, being the best player we can be as an individual and as a good teammate. Y'all look at it as like a competition. That's not really nothing I'm just focused on." He emphasized his focus on development: "I'm focused on developing as a player, like doing everything, getting as comfortable as I can in the offense in the scheme and playing with that confidence I had." On June 11, he worked mostly with the second-team offense after receiving first-team reps on June 9, hitting TE Brenden Bates and Blake Whiteheart on passes during the second-team portion (per Cleveland Browns News and Rumors June 11, 2026: The Competition Thing).
Unity camp with Watson (July 19): Before training camp opens July 28, Sanders and Deshaun Watson co-hosted a private passing camp in Miami for Browns receivers including Jerry Jeudy, Isaiah Bond, Cedric Tillman, KC Concepcion, Denzel Boston, and others. The camp reinforced the two QBs' stated commitment to supporting the receiver room development and presenting a united front despite their QB1 battle. Sanders described the camp as creating "real memories, real bonds" and emphasized neither QB would "let anything come between" their drive to be the best. Sanders flew back to Ohio to host a youth camp for 500 kids at Brooklyn High School on the same weekend, demonstrating strong community commitment and leadership presence heading into the critical preseason stretch. (per Shedeur Sanders says he and Deshaun Watson won't 'let anything come between' their bid to become the best the - Cleveland.com)
QB decision extends into preseason (June 14-15): Per ESPN's Daniel Oyefusi, Browns HC Todd Monken is holding off naming a starter and will delay the decision into preseason games. Monken wants to evaluate both Sanders and Watson in full-pads practices and game-like settings, with the Browns' first preseason game on August 15 against Chicago. This timeline suggests the QB1 job won't be finalized until late August, just before the regular season. Oyefusi specifically noted that Sanders has appeared "more poised" in Monken's offense as time progressed, with coaches lauding improvements in his footwork and processing—a meaningful development as the competition heads into the pads-on phase (per Why Browns fans will have to be patient with Shedeur Sanders vs. Deshaun Watson QB competition, Browns QB Shedeur Sanders looks 'more poised' before training camp).
Minicamp rep strategy questioned (June 16): Former Browns LB Emmanuel Acho criticized Monken's approach of splitting first-team reps between Sanders and Watson, arguing the team cannot afford to waste premium practice time if it hasn't committed to a Week 1 starter. Acho's concern: "If Shedeur is not going to start Week 1, then stop wasting first-team reps on him. If Deshaun's not gonna start Week 1, then stop wasting first-team reps on him." Through mandatory minicamp, Watson had superior stats (90 for 133 passing with 13 TDs, 3 INTs) versus Sanders (79 for 113 with 5 TDs, 3 INTs), though Sanders showed late-week momentum and improvement. Monken's balanced rotation suggests genuine uncertainty, but also reflects that the team is not ready to commit to either QB and may see this as live evaluation time rather than wasted practice reps. (per "Stop Giving Him Reps": Todd Monken Receives Bold Advice About Shedeur Sanders and Deshaun Watson From Former Browns Player - Yahoo Sports)
ESPN pre-camp QB battles assessment (July 29): Adam Schefter published a comprehensive analysis of the Browns QB competition heading into training camp, emphasizing Deshaun Watson's position as the heavy favorite despite Sanders' competitive trajectory. Schefter noted Watson's five-year, $230 million fully guaranteed contract and the Browns' organizational commitment to evaluating both QBs fairly on "merit-only" basis. However, the critical context: Watson hasn't played live football in nearly two years (Achilles surgeries in 2024-2025), creating genuine uncertainty about his readiness. Meanwhile, Sanders showed steady improvement from 2025 (7 starts, 1,400 yards, 7 TDs, 10 INTs) to spring 2026 work. Schefter's sources indicated the Browns "have to play Shedeur at some point" and suggested an AFC front-office executive's view: "My question is whether they keep Deshaun on the team if they go with [Sanders]." The two-QB approach (Watson as presumed starter + Sanders as competitive backup) positions Sanders as a potential Week 1 contender if Watson underperforms in training camp or preseason, though Watson's seniority and contract remain significant factors. Schefter's prediction: Watson wins Week 1, but Sanders will play "a representative number of games" during the 2026 season. (per 2026 NFL training camp: Predicting four QB1 battles - ESPN)
By late minicamp (June 16), Sanders had closed the gap: while Watson maintained early momentum in OTAs, by mandatory minicamp Sanders became "the more consistent quarterback of the two" for most of the three days, giving him momentum heading into training camp. Monken's credit lies in recognizing the competition remains genuinely open rather than forcing a premature decision—both Sanders and Watson functioned well enough to justify continued evaluation in pads. (per Browns minicamp 2026: Key takeaways on offense, defense and the QB race)
As training camp begins (July 25), Sanders continues to gain ground. As of mid-July, NFL insider James Palmer reported Sanders has "closed the gap" significantly on Watson, with the rookie showing improved decision-making and consistency. While Watson remains the "slight favorite," Sanders' momentum heading into camp makes the race genuinely competitive (per Latest NFL News On Where Shedeur Sanders Stands in Cleveland Browns Starting QB Battle).
FOX Sports ranks Sanders as the #2 second-year QB breakout candidate for 2026, conditional on winning the starting job over Watson. Key advantage: if named starter, Sanders will operate under new HC Todd Monken with a significantly upgraded supporting cast. The Browns invested heavily in the offensive line and added two top-40 draft picks at receiver (KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston) to complement existing talent. With better offensive infrastructure than his modest 2025 rookie season (56.6% completion, 1,400 yards, 7 TDs, 10 INTs), Sanders has clear Year 2 breakout potential—but only if he wins the ongoing competition with Watson and Monken's system installation progresses as planned. (per Year 2 Leap: Ranking The Top 5 Second-Year Quarterback Breakout Candidates)
Trade speculation unlikely (July 2026): Despite reports in early offseason that Browns hadn't ruled out trading Sanders if he loses the starting job, recent reporting from Jason La Canfora indicates teams around the league are skeptical the Browns will deal Sanders, even if Watson wins the QB job. Sources believe HC Todd Monken genuinely likes Sanders and prefers to keep him as insurance/backup rather than move him. One NFL GM told La Canfora: "Monken likes this kid. Why would they trade him now?" Another personnel executive added: "I don't think he's going anywhere." Sanders has not added significantly to his trade value since the 5th-round investment (contract is only $4.647M over four years), whereas backup QB Dillon Gabriel would be "far more expendable." This suggests Sanders will remain in Cleveland long-term regardless of Week 1 starter decision, increasing his dynasty appeal as a protected young asset (per Other Teams Skeptical Browns Will Trade Shedeur Sanders).
June 21 update — Gaining ground as competition tightens: ESPN's Jeremy Fowler reported that Sanders is "gaining ground quickly" on Watson heading into training camp. While Watson is still viewed as the favorite, Fowler noted sources credited Sanders with decisive play and a "presence" that the coaching staff may have underestimated. The QB battle is expected to extend well into preseason games before a starter is named (per Cleveland Browns 2026 training camp position battle to watch).
June 30 assessment — Watson favored, Sanders competitive: Yahoo Sports' summary of the QB race notes "the momentum appears to be favoring Deshaun Watson" despite Sanders having "closed ground on Watson in the race for the starting job with a strong showing in OTAs and mandatory minicamp." Jeremy Fowler emphasized "Most around the league expect Watson, the veteran, to get this job," though the competition will extend into preseason games. Monken remains undecided and wants to see full-pads practice and preseason action before naming a starter (per Browns QB Shedeur Sanders Gets Bad News on Future).
August 1 training camp update — Strong receiver chemistry building: Through the first four days of camp, Sanders has rotated between first and second-team reps while developing connections with receivers including Jerry Jeudy, Isaiah Bond, KC Concepcion, and Denzel Boston. Watson praised Sanders' improved fundamentals, execution, and leadership, noting: "He's definitely improved; he's grown a lot. You can see it within his fundamentals, his reads, being able to execute, call the plays. You can tell he's a lot more comfortable." Sanders and Watson had jointly hosted a private passing camp in Miami during the offseason, spending time together both on and off the field to build team chemistry heading into training camp. The unity continues into camp as both QBs work to develop receiver chemistry alongside one another (per Shedeur Sanders strives to continue improving his game in Year 2).
June 26 update — Work to do on protection and decision-making: Pro Football Focus analyst Dalton Wasserman noted Sanders has "got to learn to handle pressure better." His rookie numbers tell the story: 3-4 record in 7 starts, 7 touchdown passes, 10 interceptions, and 23 sacks taken. While his talent is evident, Sanders must improve at protecting himself, safeguarding the football, and avoiding collapsing pocket situations. The path to QB1 runs through addressing these pressure-moment fundamentals in training camp and preseason (per Cleveland Browns News and Rumors 6/26/26: Quick Hits, Old Scars, and One Smart Orangutan)
July 11 perspective — Culture fit and focus amid chaos: As the Browns prepare for training camp on July 23, Cleveland's senior director of player development James Cook expressed optimism about Sanders' approach, describing him as "continuously on the rise" and noting his ability to manage distractions. "Just getting settled and life as a pro and all those things. And obviously there's a lot of noise that comes with the person that he is and then the family he's from and all that kind of stuff. But I think he does an outstanding job of keeping the main thing the main thing," Cook told talkSPORT. Cook praised Sanders' intentionality about self-evaluation and his engagement with the organization's player development infrastructure, suggesting organizational confidence in his maturation trajectory despite the ongoing QB competition (per Shedeur Sanders' inner focus revealed as QB 'on rise' leads Browns' youth drive - talkSPORT).
August 5 first-pads breakthrough: Sanders took all first-team reps during the first padded practice at Browns training camp, significantly advancing his cause in the QB competition with Deshaun Watson. Through six total practices, Sanders has compiled a 70.5% completion rate (93 of 132 attempts) with 6 TDs and just 1 interception, showcasing improved accuracy—his trademark strength. By contrast, Watson has completed only 60.3% (76 of 126) with 6 interceptions through six practices. Head coach Todd Monken indicated both Sanders and Watson will start one preseason game each, with a QB1 decision expected ahead of the third preseason game. Sanders' first-pads dominance represents a major shift in momentum and suggests the genuine two-way competition is trending toward the second-year QB (per Shedeur Sanders outplaying Deshaun Watson at Browns' training camp)
August 2 standout practice, but context matters: On Day 4 of training camp, Sanders posted his most impressive performance yet—efficient, accurate, and showing genuine chemistry with pass catchers. Watson, by contrast, threw three interceptions and struggled throughout the day. However, beat reporters are cautioning against overreacting: pads still aren't on, there's minimal pass rush, defenses aren't game-planning, and Sanders hasn't faced the level of preparation that game planning creates. The real test will come in preseason games when defensive coordinators have studied his tendencies. Additionally, Watson hasn't taken a live hit in nearly two years due to Achilles surgeries, making his readiness under pass rush an untested variable. Despite the strong practice, the competition remains wide open (per Why Browns reporters are pumping the brakes despite Shedeur Sanders' standout practice).
June 23 — Trade speculation and QB depth: Browns have received inquiries about Sanders' availability, with Pro Football Network reporting "talks" and "ongoing calls" from other teams. However, GM Andrew Berry appears unlikely to move Sanders for anything less than a substantial offer (third-round pick or better), and no trade is imminent. The real constraint: the Browns roster four QBs (Watson, Sanders, Dillon Gabriel, Taylen Green) heading into camp, which is unusually crowded and may require roster moves to provide meaningful reps during training camp and preseason (per Cleveland Browns News and Rumors June 23, 2026: The Waiting Is the Dumbest Part)
Trade rumors underscore a deeper organizational issue: Cleveland's reluctance to invest in QB development. The front office's willingness to explore trading Sanders—despite his 3-4 record showing progress—suggests limited confidence in his long-term fit. Sports Illustrated notes this mirrors the team's failure to develop Dillon Gabriel and extends the franchise's historical pattern of skipping the development process entirely, searching instead for shortcuts (per What Trading Shedeur Sanders Would Say About Browns' Quarterback Position).
Late June training camp preview (June 24): As training camp approaches, the Sanders-Watson competition is expected to extend through August, with Todd Monken reserving judgment until full pads and preseason games provide clearer separation. Sanders has impressed with his processing, decision-making, and poise in spring drills, closing the gap significantly. The winner of this battle determines the trajectory of the Browns' passing game and offensive weapons (receivers, RBs) for 2026. (per Browns Quarterback Competition 2026: Shedeur Sanders And Deshaun Watson Head To Training Camp)
July 4 trade interest from Jets and Dolphins: Following the QB competition's extension into training camp, the New York Jets and Miami Dolphins have emerged as the most likely trade landing spots if Cleveland decides to move Sanders. Both teams face QB uncertainty for 2026: the Jets' Geno Smith is aging (35) and underperformed in 2025, while Miami's Malik Willis enters as an unproven starter. Sanders' affordable salary cap hit ($1.005M in 2026, followed by $1.12M in 2027 and $1.235M in 2028) makes him an affordable backup insurance policy or potential starter for either team, with the Dolphins particularly interested in having Sanders compete with Willis for the starting role if Willis struggles early in the season. However, trade remains unlikely unless the Browns fully commit to Watson—most analysts project Sanders remains in Cleveland heading into camp, with the option to trade him becoming available only if he clearly loses the starting competition by mid-August. (per NFL Trade Rumor: New York Jets and Miami Dolphins emerge as top landing spots for $4M Cleveland Browns' rookie)
QB battle outlook (June 30): Sportsnaut's QB competition analysis describes the Sanders-Watson battle as genuinely tight but favors Watson for Week 1 based on veteran experience and ability to function in Todd Monken's system. However, Sanders' trajectory heading into camp—improved processing, better decision-making, and coaching staff recognition—keeps him competitive. The prediction expects Watson to start Week 1 but acknowledges Sanders could win the job and take over within the first two months if he continues his current development trajectory, making it a legitimate mid-season dynamic to watch for fantasy managers. (per NFL Quarterback Battles 2026: Predicting Winners of 5 Starting QB Competitions - Sportsnaut)
Minicamp final verdict (June 24): Cleveland.com's Mary Kay Cabot reports Sanders "outplayed Deshaun in mandatory minicamp," marking a significant momentum shift heading into training camp. Cabot characterizes Sanders as an "empirical learner" who needs real, live repetitions to absorb complex concepts, but once they click, "they click hard"—a learning style that explains both his slow start and explosive finish in spring. Head coach Todd Monken deliberately avoided naming a starter to keep the competition open, unwilling to hand Watson the job prematurely. Meanwhile, Watson faces a critical unknown: how will he perform under live pass rush after nearly two years without contact due to Achilles surgeries and shoulder work? Monken understands there's nothing to gain by ending the competition in June when pads-on practice and preseason will provide definitive answers. (per Browns' QB competition remains wide open heading into training camp)
Training camp positioning (June 24-28): Heading into 2026 training camp, Shedeur Sanders has momentum on his side. Sanders was noted as having led first-team drills recently at OTAs and minicamp despite inconsistent production so far. The real evaluation begins once the pads come on—spring football provides no pass rush or live tackling, so the QB competition will shift dramatically when full contact begins. Watson's edge lies in his ability to create off-schedule and absorb the physical side of the position, while Sanders must prove that his spring efficiency holds up against live pressure. Training camp will reveal who can operate an offense when a defensive end is bearing down and the pocket is collapsing. Preseason games will carry more weight than usual, with Monken planning to rotate his top two heavily through August before making a final decision (per Browns Quarterback Competition 2026: Shedeur Sanders And Deshaun Watson Head To Training Camp and 2026 NFL training camp preview: Five storylines to monitor). Watson remains the organizational favorite, but Sanders' rapid development trajectory—from 3-4 record as a rookie to potentially winning a starting job—positions him as a genuine threat.
Oddsmakers track training camp battles (July 20): Las Vegas sportsbooks view the Sanders vs. Watson competition in Cleveland as one of the most intriguing QB battles heading into 2026. The competition is considered "wide open" by major sportsbooks, with both quarterbacks working out with skill players during the week. Risk managers note that QB competitions are the ones that "really move game lines, futures markets above anything else," underscoring the broader impact of the Sanders-Watson decision on betting markets (per NFL Training Camps Open with QB Battles Driving Betting Lines).
June 2026 position battle assessment: PFSN's 32-team position battle roundup describes the Browns QB matchup as "the NFL's most unpredictable battle," with Sanders having invested heavily in receiver upgrades (Carnell Tate, denzel Boston) that may unlock his potential if he wins the job. (per 32-team position battles—Cleveland QBs, Seattle RBs to watch)
July 13 analysis — Strong case for Sanders heading into training camp: Yahoo Sports details why Sanders should win the starting job despite Watson's veteran status. Key points: Sanders' 3-4 record in seven 2025 starts masks team success—Cleveland went 3-1 with Sanders as starter after opening 1-11 without him. His Week 14 performance (364 yards, 3 TDs, 1 rushing TD vs. Titans) earned him a Pro Bowl replacement nod and ranks among the best single games by a rookie QB in Browns history. Coaching staff specifically highlighted footwork and processing improvements—the two traits critical to success in Monken's system. Watson's durability after a double Achilles rupture (October 2024 tear, re-rupture during rehab, second surgery within 12 weeks) presents an organizational risk: can Cleveland trust Watson to stay healthy through December? The analytic edge: young QBs only need to break even against fading veterans because organizational investment already points toward the future. Sanders' only requirement is to match Watson's performance, not surpass it significantly. Preseason reps and joint practices (Bills on August 20) will likely prove decisive, with a mid-to-late August decision expected (per Shedeur Sanders Will Be The Browns Starting Quarterback: 3 Reasons The Job Is His To Lose)
July 18 concern — Effort and commitment wavering (latest): Pro Football Talk's Mike Florio flagged a concerning development in recent OTA practices: Sanders appeared to coast through a fake-pitch drill where Watson executed cleanly and delivered a sharp throw. Florio warned Sanders directly: "You can't win the job if this is how you're going to approach these drills. You've got to put everything into it, or Watson is the guy who's going to earn the job." The concern resonates given Sanders' rookie interception problem: 10 INTs in his first 8 career games raised red flags about pocket judgment that Spring training must address. However, NFL Network reporter Tom Pelissero offered a more balanced perspective, emphasizing Watson's durability risk—the veteran has appeared in just 19 games across 5 seasons with Cleveland due to shoulder, rotator cuff, and double Achilles injuries, creating organizational uncertainty about his health trajectory (per Shedeur Sanders' half-effort OTA reps give Deshaun Watson a real shot at Browns QB1, Florio warns)
Mobility questions re-evaluated (July 4): Former draft scout Daniel Kelly criticized Sanders for being "way too slow," pointing to his 4.68 40-yard dash. However, HC Todd Monken countered the criticism with context: "15 or 20 years ago, they would have said that Shedeur Sanders was athletic...the game's changed so much." Monken acknowledged Sanders isn't as mobile as elite modern QBs like Lamar Jackson but credited him with genuine "knack" and "feel" for playmaking off-schedule. Sanders' rookie rushing stats (169 yards, 1 TD) are minimal, and he remains primarily a pure passer. Head coach Monken believes the mobility question is overblown given the offensive design and Sanders' demonstrated ability to "move around the pocket" and "get himself out of trouble," though teams will continue evaluating his athleticism in live practice and preseason settings (per 'He's Way Too Slow': Shedeur Sanders Gets Harsh Evaluation Amid Browns QB Battle With Deshaun Watson - Yahoo Sports).
July 6 momentum shift — Sanders keeping race alive: Mary Kay Cabot and Dan Labbe's latest Orange and Brown Talk podcast reveals Sanders "really took the bull by the horns" after falling behind Watson in spring OTAs, with his competitive fire and improved performance in Monken's offense keeping the race genuinely alive. By end of mandatory minicamp, Sanders made "real strides" in pre-snap operation, managing protections, and working through progressions—areas that were major concerns coming out of the draft. Cabot noted visible momentum shift toward the finish line: "There's a lot of things that Shedeur seemed to be doing better as the spring went along, and Deshaun kind of faded a little bit towards the end." Watson's accuracy noticeably dipped in final days of mandatory minicamp, with Cabot carefully noting possible fatigue from surgically repaired shoulder. Sanders appeared "more poised" and "more confident" in Monken's system, making him competitive heading into training camp. Monken declined to name a starter, suggesting genuine uncertainty. Per Cabot, Sanders needs two things: faster release and sharper pre-snap decision-making. If he demonstrates these consistently, the opportunity to seize the starting job is "real and present." (per Shedeur Sanders keeps Browns QB race alive heading into training camp)
June 10 reality check — Real competition hasn't started: HC Todd Monken gave a stark assessment: both Sanders and Watson have "played well enough to earn the right to compete," but the actual competition hasn't begun. Through minicamp, the two QBs were working in alternating shifts with the first team rather than genuinely competing against each other. Monken explicitly stated: "Once we get to the fall, we'll have to dissect the reps how we see fit." This means full competition will begin in training camp with pads on, and the decision likely won't be made until after preseason games. Monken expressed hope for a Week 1 decision but acknowledged "in a perfect world, you'd love to have your starting quarterback... I'm not sure we'll be there." For fantasy purposes, Sanders' viability depends on winning a job that won't be decided until late August (per Todd Monken gives troubling update on Browns' quarterback competition)
Trade value minimal (June 30): Pro Football Network analyst Joe DeLeone assessed Sanders' trade market as effectively nonexistent. He stated no team would trade for Sanders unless in "a situation where a team suffers a devastating injury to its starter," and even then unlikely. DeLeone cited Sanders' unproven commodity status and the media distraction that accompanies him as a backup—teams worry about roster noise and sideshow coverage. DeLeone believes it's more likely Sanders steps into Cleveland's starting role at some point in 2026 than being traded away. (per 'Who Is Going To Trade For Shedeur Sanders?' — NFL Analyst Drops Blunt Verdict On Browns QB Amid Growing Speculation)
Sports Illustrated ranks Sanders as a preseason sleeper QB, listed as QB33 in early 2026 rankings. Under new HC Todd Monken's offense, Sanders' intriguing young weapons at receiver (Jerry Jeudy, KC Concepcion, Denzel Boston) and tight end (Harold Fannin Jr.) position him for sleeper value if he wins the starting job. If Sanders can avoid turnovers and function competently, he has upside to trend toward 230+ passing yards per game. The competition with Deshaun Watson heading into training camp will determine his fantasy ceiling. Per SI's AFC North sleeper analysis, the Browns QB starter—whether Sanders or Watson—will benefit from their upgraded receiver core (Jeudy at 1,229 yards in 2024 form, plus rookie additions Concepcion and Boston) and top-5 TE Harold Fannin Jr., making the position a league-winning sleeper if Sanders takes the job. (per The Top Fantasy Football Sleepers in the AFC North Including Shedeur Sanders)
July 17-18 team-unity workout: As training camp approaches, Sanders and Watson worked out together in Florida with teammates including Jerry Jeudy, Isaiah Bond, Denzel Boston, and Dylan Sampson. Sanders explicitly stated the two QBs won't allow competitive framing to create division: "I think we're a team. If one of us choose to do something, we're all gonna do it together. It's not no individual thing." The coordinated session reinforces both QBs' commitment to keeping the battle non-contentious and team-focused rather than fostering personal rivalry. Both participated in the throwing session, alternating reps to receivers. NFL insider Jeremy Fowler observed that "this is a true, heated battle" but noted Watson "was moving like a major athlete again coming off those Achilles tears" and looked fluid, while Sanders has "bridged the gap at least somewhat" and Watson "moved like a major athlete" suggesting strong recovery from surgeries. Fowler still believes Watson is "in a good position" but acknowledged Sanders' competitive trajectory keeps the race alive heading into full-pads practice (per Shedeur Sanders and Deshaun Watson keep their promise ahead of training camp, Shedeur Sanders, Deshaun Watson Work Out Together in Video Amid Browns QB1 Competition, Browns' Shedeur Sanders, Deshaun Watson Work Out Together Amid QB1 Battle).
July 9 update — Sanders momentum building; competition wide open: Bleacher Report's James Palmer reported Sanders has "closed the gap" between himself and Watson for the starting QB job. While Watson had an early advantage through minicamp, that edge has eroded. NBC Sports' Kyle Dvorchak noted: "After getting a better look at both players, it sounds like new head coach Todd Monken truly doesn't know who will take the first snap this year. By virtue of not being Deshaun Watson, Sanders has forced a legitimate training camp competition." Monken emphasized both QBs have "played well enough to earn the right to compete." Most around the league still expects Watson to get the job, but Sanders' trajectory and improved play are keeping the race alive heading into training camp and preseason (per Analyst gives insight into Browns QB battle with training camp next).
July 21 analysis — Watson's veteran advantage cited as edge: Bleacher Report's Alex Kay reassessed the QB competition heading into training camp, noting Watson's "proven talents" and veteran credentials could give him the edge over Sanders if he stays healthy. Kay acknowledged Sanders' Pro Bowl rookie season (1,400 passing yards, 7 TDs, 10 INTs, 3-4 record) but emphasized that new HC Todd Monken "has no stake in his [Sanders'] success" and will prioritize starting the best available player. While the competition has tightened significantly, Kay's analysis positions Watson's career history as a potential deciding factor in a close race (per Will Deshaun Watson's 'Proven Talents' Help Him Win Browns' Starting QB Job?)
July 9 skill comparison — Accuracy edge for Sanders: Beat reporter Mary Kay Cabot's deep dive on the Orange and Brown Talk podcast crystallizes the key distinction between the two QBs: Sanders holds a clear accuracy advantage, finding tight windows and delivering with precision into Todd Monken's QB-centric system. Watson counters with elite athleticism and the ability to extend plays off-schedule—a skill set neither QB can fully replicate. The critical unknown: Watson's post-surgery athleticism remains untested in live situations after double Achilles procedures. Cabot frames the dilemma starkly: "If you could morph these two guys together, you would have everything you need in a quarterback." Cleveland's choice will hinge on whether Sanders' accuracy sufficiency outweighs Watson's athletic upside in an injury-recovery unknown (per Shedeur Sanders leads in accuracy, Deshaun Watson in athleticism in Browns QB battle).
July 11 league sentiment shifts toward Sanders: Yahoo Sports analyst Frank Schwab raised a stark warning about Watson winning the Browns' starting job. Schwab noted Watson's off-field past and poor play in Cleveland ("it will be very unpopular if Watson actually wins the Browns' starting job, considering his off-field past and how badly he has played in Cleveland since the Browns traded three first-round picks and more to the Texans for him"). Schwab characterized the team's preparation for Watson to start as "bizarre," suggesting Sanders' stronger on-field performance should dictate the outcome. This sentiment shifts toward Sanders heading into camp: his modest rookie numbers (1,400 yards, 7 TDs, 10 INTs, 68.1 rating in 7 starts) appear more promising than Watson's continued struggles, positioning Sanders as the preferred choice despite Watson's veteran status (per Browns should heed warning amid Shedeur Sanders, Deshaun Watson QB competition).
July 3 receiving room depth: Sports Illustrated's latest analysis notes that while the Browns have drafted unproven receivers (Concepcion, Boston), adding veteran help like Stefon Diggs would stabilize Sanders' environment. Diggs is a free agent still unsigned after a strong 2025 with New England (85 rec, 1,013 yards, 4 TDs). The article positions a potential Diggs signing as beneficial for Sanders—pairing a young QB in a "prove-it" season with an elite veteran route technician who has proven he can work with second-year signal-callers. If Diggs lands in Cleveland, it would significantly upgrade the receiving corps and reduce Sanders' dependence on inexperienced draft picks to establish rhythm (per Who Will Sign Stefon Diggs?: 3 Potential Suitors And Their Fantasy Football Impact).
July 8 self-improvement focus: Yardbarker reported Sanders released a YouTube video emphasizing his goal to "block out the noise" and focus entirely on self-improvement rather than directly competing with Watson. Sanders stated his priority is "improving his own game and becoming the best quarterback he can be," a disciplined mindset heading into training camp. However, NFL analyst Nick Baumgardner of The Athletic identified a critical flaw holding Sanders back: he tends to operate on "Shedeur Sanders time" rather than following team play timing. This tendency created major problems in his rookie year: he took 23 sacks in just 7 games, which projects to 56 sacks over a 17-game season. To win the job, Sanders must fix his footwork, learn to trust the play design, and stop holding the ball too long. Coach Todd Monken emphasized Sanders needs to address these timing and protection issues if he's to seize the starting opportunity. (per Shedeur Sanders sends bold message about NFL future amid Browns QB battle with Deshaun Watson - Yardbarker)
June 25 trade proposal: A Bleacher Report trade proposal envisions a three-team deal sending Sanders to Arizona in exchange for veteran backup Jacoby Brissett and New England's third-round pick, allowing the Browns to bridge the gap until the 2027 draft. The proposal would move Sanders out of Cleveland if he continues losing the Watson competition, though the deal remains speculative and GM Andrew Berry has not signaled willingness to move Sanders for anything less than a substantial offer. (per Browns ship out Shedeur Sanders in proposed trade from Bleacher Report)
July 17 training camp preview: Cleveland.com reports Sanders has pulled into a tie with Watson heading into training camp. After earning first-team reps on June 9, Sanders closed the gap during spring ball. Coach Todd Monken cites Sanders' improved decisiveness and quicker release as key strengths, though Sanders must cut down on interceptions (7 TDs, 10 INTs as a rookie) to seize the job. Sanders' main edge: accuracy over Watson, who missed shorter throws during OTAs and minicamp. Monken emphasized both QBs "can start and play winning football," but the decision will extend into preseason games (per Can Shedeur Sanders beat out Deshaun Watson for the Browns starting quarterback job?: 15 questions for '26).
Late July training camp approach (July 23): Monken's coaching philosophy toward the QB competition reflects genuine respect for Sanders, rooted in his prior role as Baltimore offensive coordinator where he actively sought Sanders in the 2025 draft. When Sanders was drafted by Cleveland instead, Monken later told the young QB: "Hey, we tried to draft your ass last year for God's sake! It all worked out. You remember that, right?" The shoulder pull and personal affinity signal Monken's belief in Sanders' potential, contrasting with his unfamiliarity with Watson (the two have never worked together). Sanders continues to benefit from Monken's coaching tree advantage over Watson, making the competition less purely merit-based and more influenced by coach-player chemistry. (per Shedeur Sanders vs Deshaun Watson: How one preseason battle could reshape two NFL careers)
Training camp opens (July 28): As NFL training camps begin, the Browns' QB competition between Sanders and Watson officially kicks off. Monken indicated both QBs have had "really good springs" and called it a positive time to be the Browns' head coach. The evaluation will extend through pads-on practice and preseason games before a final decision is made. (per NFL training camps set to open with 10 new head coaches, several QB changes and plenty of hope)
Aug 4 executive poll — rival defenses skeptical: Sports Illustrated's Mike Sando released his annual quarterback tiers with harsh assessments from rival defensive coordinators and executives. Sanders ranked No. 35 overall, placing a dozen voters in Tier 5 (the lowest possible option). One defensive coordinator quipped he'd "sleep like a baby" if he got to play Sanders weekly, while another criticized his accuracy: "He's inaccurate at all three levels...there's a huge gap between him and competent quarterback play." A different coordinator was more specific: "He's not an on-time player, can't really read through the coverages, is a little bit heavy-footed," though acknowledging he's "thicker and harder to tackle than expected." For context, Watson ranked No. 31 in the same poll. HC Todd Monken countered this narrative by publicly praising Sanders' progress: "I've been highly impressed over the last four months that I've been around him how far he's come as a player, and he's only going to continue to get better." Monken emphasized Sanders' mechanics and decision-making improvements, stating: "I think you'll continue to see his operation and mechanics improve." (per NFL Executives Slam Shedeur Sanders in Latest Quarterback Poll - Sports Illustrated)
Aug 5 psychological edge — Sanders supremely confident: During an interview at training camp, Sanders offered a telling answer when asked about competing with Watson and Gabriel. Sanders responded: "Yeah, I have. Me vs myself." His answer suggested he's not concerned about his competition's performance—instead, he views the starting job as contingent solely on his own execution. "I have the position if I bring my A-game," Sanders' answer implied, showing psychological confidence heading into the critical preseason evaluation window. (per Shedeur Sanders reveals who he's really competing with in Browns QB battle amid Deshaun Watson uncertainty - Yahoo Sports)
Aug 4 training camp assessment — Sanders making bigger plays, rotation format questioned: Through five days of training camp, beat reporter Mary Kay Cabot noted Sanders has "made more big plays and better plays than Deshaun Watson so far." Sanders capped a two-minute drill with a deep ball to Tylan Wallace and a perfectly placed fade route to Gage Larvadain—plays showcasing accuracy when he has a clean pocket. However, Cleveland.com reporters questioned whether head coach Todd Monken's alternating-day rep structure (one QB gets starters one day, the other the next) is serving either player well. The concern: rhythm and timing are everything at quarterback position. Working with new offensive linemen, new receivers, and a brand-new system, building consecutive-day continuity with the same offensive group could go a long way toward generating real consistency. Neither QB gets that currently, which may be "artificially compressing the development of both." Sanders has consistently gotten most reps alongside rookies KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston, and that trio has built real chemistry that could factor into the final decision if Sanders and his receivers continue "lighting it up together." (per The 1 thing about the Browns' QB rotation that could be hurting both Watson and Sanders)
Aug 5 preseason evaluation plan: Head coach Todd Monken has mapped out how the QB competition will be evaluated during preseason games. Sanders and Watson will each start one of Cleveland's first two preseason games: one will open against Chicago on Aug. 15, the other against Buffalo on Aug. 22. Monken hasn't yet decided who gets the first opportunity but indicated the next week of practice will likely determine the order. Both QBs will then compete for the third preseason game against New England on Aug. 27, with the leader after two games likely earning that start. This structure gives each QB a meaningful game evaluation before the Week 1 decision is finalized. (per Browns Make First QB Decision Between Shedeur Sanders, Deshaun Watson)
Aug 9 rep balancing — Not a Watson endorsement: On practice day 10 of training camp (Aug 9), coach Todd Monken gave Watson all first-team snaps. Initial reports suggested this was a sign Monken leans toward Watson, but beat reporter Mary Kay Cabot quickly clarified the real reason: the two QBs were working on different daily rotations (alternating every other day) while pads came on and off on their own schedule, causing rep imbalance. Sanders had received 3 padded practices with the starters; Watson only 1. Monken switched to give Watson more padded reps to equalize the evaluation: "Not on purpose," Monken said. "It was just every other day." The pads came off and went back on according to their own calendar. The quarterbacks alternated according to a different one. Things got out of sync. Saturday was the last padded practice before coaches evaluated both QBs for the Chicago preseason game (Aug. 15). Cabot and other beat reporters confirmed the story holds: this was arithmetic to balance evaluation opportunities, not a decision favoring Watson. Both QBs need equivalent full-pads evaluation before Monken decides who starts Week 1 (per Cleveland Browns News and Rumors 8/10/26: The Boring Answer, Sitting There the Whole Time).
Aug 12 preseason assignment — Sanders to start vs. Buffalo: After naming Watson to start the Chicago preseason game (Aug. 15), Browns HC Todd Monken assigned Sanders to start vs. Buffalo on Aug. 22, with the winner earning the third preseason game vs. New England on Aug. 27 before the Week 1 starter is finalized. This structured evaluation window will determine whether Watson's veteran status and early edge hold or whether Sanders' training camp momentum carries into preseason success. Sanders made impressive plays in training camp and connected with draft pick receivers KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston repeatedly, but Watson received edge in final week of pads due to needing rep balancing and his strong days late in camp. (per Browns name Watson starting QB for preseason opener)
Aug 10 training camp update — QB decision remains "really close": As training camp progresses, new Browns HC Todd Monken labeled the ongoing QB1 race between Sanders and Watson as "really close" ahead of the preseason evaluation window. Monken continues to deliberately split reps with the first-team offense, and notably took first-team reps on Aug 8 on what was slated to be Sanders' scheduled day—a signal that the reps are being managed for evaluation purposes rather than indicating a starter. Monken has committed to rotating both QBs through preseason games before making a final decision. (per NFL training camp live updates, news, injuries for Aug. 10 - USA Today, NFL Rumors: $66 Million Quarterback Abruptly Retires, Shedeur Sanders Dealt News on Browns QB).
Aug 15 preseason opener vs Bears — Watson edges Sanders in first opportunity: After Watson started the Chicago game, Sanders entered in the third quarter for his preseason evaluation opportunity. Sanders completed 6 of 11 passes for 79 yards and threw one interception while fumbling a snap snap early in his drives. Watson led the only scoring drives of the half (field goal and TD) while Sanders' unit went three-and-out multiple times. The game did not resolve the competition but reinforced Watson's organizational edge heading into Sanders' start vs. Buffalo on August 22 (per Deshaun Watson outplays Shedeur Sanders in preseason opener, but Browns QB battle...).
Aug 5 preseason start allocation — Sanders to start one of first two games: Brown HC Todd Monken announced Sanders will get one preseason start in the first two preseason matchups against Chicago (Aug 15) or Buffalo (Aug 22). Watson will start the other game Sanders doesn't start, with the winner between the two earning the third preseason game against New England on Aug 27 before the Week 1 decision is finalized. Monken has not yet decided which game Sanders will get (per Browns Will Give QBs Deshaun Watson & Shedeur Sanders One Start Each In Preseason).
Aug 4 NFL executive poll — ranked last among 35 QBs: Sports Illustrated's Mike Sando released his annual quarterback tiers with harsh assessments from rival defensive coordinators and executives. Sanders ranked No. 35—dead last—with just one Tier 3 vote while receiving 37 Tier 4 tallies and 12 Tier 5 votes (lowest possible). One defensive coordinator stated he'd "sleep like a baby" if he got to play Sanders every week. Another criticized his accuracy: "He's inaccurate at all three levels. I can't tell if he is going to get better, but there's a huge gap between him and competent QB play." A third coordinator added: "He's not an on-time player, can't really read through the coverages, is a little bit heavy-footed, but you shouldn't lose to him." For context, Watson ranked No. 31 in the same poll. HC Todd Monken publicly defended Sanders in response, saying: "I've been highly impressed over the last four months...how far he's come as a player." This poll snapshot captures league-wide skepticism about Sanders despite training camp's more optimistic picture from the Browns' coaching staff (per NFL executives, coaches put Shedeur Sanders last in QB rankings in survey: 'Shouldn't lose to him'). Yahoo Sports corroborated the pessimism, reporting Sanders lands "a brutal take from NFL execs" (per Browns' Shedeur Sanders Lands Brutal Take From NFL Execs).
Aug 23 preseason Week 2: Sanders completed 9 of 11 passes for 74 yards with 1 TD and 1 INT against Buffalo, earning a B+ grade from coach Todd Monken. He showed marked improvement in pocket management and the ability to step up under pressure—two areas that drew criticism in his rookie season. Sanders demonstrated superior discipline and footwork when pressured, avoiding the negative plays that plagued his 2025 campaign. The interception came on a tipped pass, not a poor decision. The solid 81.8% efficiency and improved processing marked Sanders' strongest outing yet, giving him genuine momentum heading into the third preseason game against New England, where the QB1 job will likely be decided (per Shedeur Sanders states case as Browns starter: Instant analysis, grade and NFL news, live updates: Shedeur Sanders, Jayden Daniels see action in Week 2 of preseason).
Aug 25 decision — Watson named starter, Sanders to backup: HC Todd Monken announced that Deshaun Watson will be the Cleveland Browns' starting QB for Week 1 against Jacksonville, with Shedeur Sanders designated as the backup. Monken credited Sanders with closing the gap throughout the preseason evaluation but ultimately favored Watson's veteran experience and full body of work: "We felt over the course of training camp and the offseason that (Watson) was ahead of Shedeur...Shedeur's closed that gap, for sure. And that's a credit to him." Monken stated he does "not anticipate" week-to-week changes in the starting role, though Sanders remains positioned to play if Watson struggles early or faces injury. Sanders will continue his development as Cleveland's QB2 heading into the regular season, with opportunities to prove his 2026 readiness as the backup option. (per NFL news, live updates: Browns announce Deshaun Watson as starter over Shedeur Sanders)
What the decision reveals (Aug 25 analysis): Cleveland.com's Jimmy Watkins offered a provocative interpretation of Monken's choice: for the Browns to elevate Deshaun Watson—a historically poor performer with the franchise, facing durability concerns after double Achilles rupture, and toxic home-stadium relationship—over Sanders suggests the organization doesn't see star potential in the rookie QB. Watkins noted that any NFL team given the choice would prefer a young first-round talent over a failed expensive veteran, making Watson's selection a damning statement about Sanders' readiness rather than Watson's superiority. The implicit message: Brown's coaching staff sees Sanders' shortcomings as significant enough to justify starting a two-time injured, 19-game veteran over a draft pick the team selected to potentially lead them to the future. (per What does the Browns' embarrassing quarterback decision say about Shedeur Sanders?)
Role / Depth Chart
Competing with Deshaun Watson for starting QB role. Started 7 games in rookie season after entering as backup to Flacco and Gabriel. Fantasy relevance depends heavily on whether he wins or loses the quarterback competition before Week 1 against Jacksonville.
Injury Status
Healthy.
Recent News
- 2026-08-27 — Shedeur Sanders could regain Browns’ starting QB job (Shedeur Sanders could regain Browns’ starting QB job)
- 2026-08-28 — Ryan Fitzpatrick believes Deshaun Watson will fail as Browns QB (Ryan Fitzpatrick believes Deshaun Watson will fail as Browns QB)
- 2026-08-28 — Should Dillon Gabriel's electric preseason finale force Browns to rethink QB1 decision? (Should Dillon Gabriel's electric preseason finale force Browns to rethink QB1 decision?)
- 2026-08-26 — Browns Quarterback Decision Could Leave Shedeur Sanders’ Future in Doubt (Browns Quarterback Decision Could Leave Shedeur Sanders’ Future in Doubt)
- 2026-08-23 — Browns expect to name starting QB on Monday; Deshaun Watson’s comments won’t impact... (Browns expect to name starting QB on Monday; Deshaun Watson’s comments won’t impact...)
- 2026-08-24 — Browns make starting quarterback decision after Deshaun Watson-Shedeur Sanders battle (Browns make starting quarterback decision after Deshaun Watson-Shedeur Sanders battle)
- 2026-08-24 — Browns name Deshaun Watson starting QB for Week 1 of 2026 season (Browns name Deshaun Watson starting QB for Week 1 of 2026 season)
- 2026-08-24 — Deshaun Watson named Browns' QB1, says he regrets fan comments (Deshaun Watson named Browns' QB1, says he regrets fan comments)
- 2026-08-24 — Deshaun Watson named Browns’ starting quarterback (Deshaun Watson named Browns’ starting quarterback)
- 2026-08-25 — What does the Browns’ embarrassing quarterback decision say about Shedeur Sanders? —... (What does the Browns’ embarrassing quarterback decision say about Shedeur Sanders? —...)
Open Questions
- Will Shedeur Sanders win the starting QB job for the Browns in 2026, or will he remain a backup to Deshaun Watson?